walkitout (walkitout) wrote,

_Uncommon Passion_, Anne Calhoun (kindle) SPOILERS RUN IN FEAR AAAAUUUUGH

There were a couple of shorter stories related to this full length novel. It is contemporary romance/erotica set in Galveston. The protagonist, Ben, appeared in the earlier stories. He is a cop, with a twin brother, estranged from the rest of his family and Ben's disavowed need to reconnect with that family constitutes the core obstacle to the romance. He is also a bouncer at a raunchy night club called No Limits, that figures more significantly in the earlier stories than in this one. There are some internal indications that there may be further stories/novels involving minor characters.

The other protagonist, Rachel, has relatively recently (some months back) cut ties with her father (only remaining immediate family) and the religious community in which she was raised and home schooled. The first major problem I had with the book was the idea of an extremely Christian religious community being named Elysian Fields. I sort of didn't believe it, but I'm willing to listen to justification/rationalization/explanation.

The second major problem I had with the book was how Rachel got out. She was homeschooled, and access to the internet was apparently available to a limited degree in the community but it was supposedly highly controlled. It's unclear to me how she put together any kind of escape plan and hers was clearly _really effective_ the first time, as she connected with social workers, a shelter, and they helped her (this is in the backstory, and communicated with admirable concision) get documentation in order to survive in the world outside. I also sort of didn't buy the idea that you could be as stable as Rachel appeared to be, with as little communication/close friendships as she had/has at the time the story takes place. On the one hand, she's super with the non-verbals, and that counts for a lot. But still.

I utterly believed the idea that Rachel would immediately identify Ben as a good person to unload her virginity with. He had I-will-avoid-all-commitment written all over him, and that's what she was looking for. And, not unexpectedly, that desire on her part, paired with her stunning ability to generate meaningful human connection from remarkably little verbal communication, caused him to want to come back for more. Rachel's developing sexuality is handled in a nuanced and creative way (I would expect no less of this author), as is Ben's slow-motion but nevertheless total psychological collapse.

If you're prepared to believe the premise (hey, I read books about werewolves and vampires and Fae and wtf; believing someone is preternaturally emotionally self-contained AND stable shouldn't bug me that much, amirite?), then this is a fantastic book, perhaps Calhoun's best.

Alas, while I wasn't home schooled, and I didn't have the degree of agrarian isolation that Rachel had, I grew up in a very socially isolated way, and I similarly plotted my escape. I'm not necessarily as stable or self-contained as Rachel (the self-contained part I find particularly unbelievable -- humans don't really work that way), but even if I were, the difficulties presented by the transition she experienced are more destabilizing than they were presented. So park me in the I Can't Accept That Premise column, along with many other readers.

This in no way prevents me from loving Calhoun's work, and being fully prepared to come back for more.
Tags: book review
  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.